TradeDay has faced criticism for its lack of transparency and overly complicated evaluation process, which can be discouraging for many traders. The profit-sharing model is less competitive compared to other firms, leaving traders with smaller returns. Additionally, the trading tools and platforms provided lack innovation and can feel outdated, making it harder for traders to execute advanced strategies. Customer support is often slow to respond, and the educational resources offered are limited, providing little value for traders looking to grow. Overall, TradeDay may not meet the expectations of traders seeking a supportive and rewarding prop trading experience.